MagikFlame vs Dimplex - two top brands in the electric fireplace space. There’s a lot of overlap between the two in terms of sizes, designs, and features - but it’s the differences between MagikFlame and Dimplex that matter most. We’re here to break them down for you.
We’re the #1 choice for a Dimplex fireplace online. This brand offers one of the widest lineups on the market, ranging from linear models like the Ignite series, the Opti-Myst water vapor fireplace series, and full-depth Revillusion fireboxes designed to replace traditional wood or gas units. You get flexible design options, proven flame technology, and durability you can trust.
MagikFlame fireplaces are best known for their patented HoloFlame® technology, which uses real video fire projected onto a physical log set, paired with built-in sound effects and software-driven updates. They’re generally more expensive than Dimplex fireplaces.
But price is just one reason we think Dimplex is the smarter choice. You get more styles to choose from, better installation flexibility, and world-class customer service when you shop Dimplex Fireplaces at The Great Fire Company.
Learn more about Dimplex vs MagikFlame below to make the most informed decision for your home or business. Or, connect with our team today for a personalized recommendation!
MagikFlame vs Dimplex (Fast Facts)
|
Category |
Dimplex |
MagikFlame |
|
Best for |
Buyers who want the right fit for their wall, room, and install type with lots of model choices. |
Buyers who want a realism-first insert + mantel experience with built-in sound and themed visuals. |
|
Flame technology |
Dimplex Flame Effect, Revillusion depth, and Opti-Myst water-vapor flames. |
Patented HoloFlame® holographic video fire projected onto a physical log set. |
|
Product types |
Linear fireplaces, traditional built-ins, inserts, log sets, and water-vapor cassettes. |
Electric inserts and mantel packages. |
|
Size range (examples) |
Ignite lines run 50"–100"; Ignite Aspire offers 30"–48"; many other series cover 18"–86"+. |
Varies by insert/mantel lineup; flame styles are the headline feature more than width range. |
|
Installation flexibility |
Broad: built-in, linear, cassette/modular, and retrofit-friendly options depending on series. |
Simpler: designed around insert installs and mantel builds rather than many form factors. |
|
Customization |
Customizable ember beds, flame settings, and lighting options vary by series. |
30 flame styles plus sound effects and themed options (including a virtual fish tank). |
|
Controls |
Remote/on-unit controls are common; some lines have app-based control. |
Remote + iOS Bluetooth app; software updates delivered via Wi-Fi. |
|
Heat approach |
Designed for ambiance + supplemental heat; many models run flames with or without heat. |
Infrared quartz heater for zone heating; ambiance-only mode available. |
|
Maintenance |
Low: no venting, no fuel, no ash; routine dusting and basic care. |
Low: no venting, no fuel, no ash; routine dusting and basic care. |
|
Cost |
Starting at $1,249 at The Great Fire Company. Generally more affordable. |
Starting over $3,200 - a more premium option because of the flame technology. |
Why We Love Dimplex Fireplaces
Dimplex has been building electric fireplaces for decades. You could fairly say the brand has shaped the modern fireplace industry as we know it today. There are a few series in particular that we want to highlight:
Ignite® Series (Bold, Evolve, Ultra, XL, Aspire)
This is the linear fireplace lineup from Dimplex, one of our best-selling series here at The Great Fire Company. These units are made to install seamlessly into walls with clean glass fronts and long, horizontal flame views.
Sizes range from the Ignite Aspire at 30”-48” to large-format models such as Ignite Bold, Ultra, and XL running from 50” up to 100”. Features include adjustable flame colors, ember bed lighting, multiple installation configurations, and optional hardwire capability.
Opti-Myst® / Optimyst® Series
One of the most unique fireplace technologies in the world. These units use water vapor and LED lighting to create a true 3D flame and smoke effect.
The Cassette, Linear, Pro Box, and Revive are often used in custom builds, open hearth designs, or retrofit projects where realism matters more than anything. Sizes range from compact cassettes to long linear units up to 86”, with modular layouts available.
Revillusion® Series
These fireplaces replace a traditional wood or gas fireplace. You get deeper fireboxes, brick-style interiors, and realistic log placement. Available in 24”-42” sizes, including portrait options. These classic-style units work well in living rooms, bedrooms, and renovation projects.
The Best Balance of Flexibility, Durability, and Affordability
Across the board, Dimplex fireplaces give you options. We know that no two installations are exactly the same, which is why we’re proud to carry the full range from Dimplex so our customers never have to compromise on style or performance.
These fireplaces are built to last, too. They’re a smart investment in your home or business, backed by as long as a 5-year warranty, depending on the series. And when you buy yours here at The Great Fire Company, you get top-tier customer support from A to Z.
Our blog has more resources on Dimplex vs SimpliFire, Dimplex vs Modern Flames, and Dimplex vs Napoleon electric fireplace, if you want to browse other options. But you came here to learn about Dimplex vs MagikFlame - so let’s introduce the other half of this comparison.
What Does MagikFlame Bring to the Hearth Space?
MagikFlame has only been around a decade, but the brand has already made a name for itself, creating electric fireplaces with a focus on realism. These fireplaces produce flame effects the like of which are indistinguishable from gas/wood fireplaces.
It makes sense, since the American-owned brand was brought to life by a former film special-effects expert. Let’s take a closer look at the different products MagikFlame makes.
MagikFlame HoloFlame® Inserts
The patented HoloFlame® insert is what makes these fireplaces unlike anything else on the market. Instead of simulated flame lighting, MagikFlame uses actual video footage of real fires projected onto a physical log set.
The end result from this technology is visible flame movement, ember glow, and subtle smoke effects that look way more convincing than traditional LED-based systems.
Inserts can be retrofitted into existing fireplace openings or paired with MagikFlame mantels. That’s one of the key differences between MagikFlame vs Dimplex - this brand doesn’t support as wide a range of linear or wall-mounted installs.
Mantel Fireplace Packages
Most MagikFlame products are sold as insert-and-mantel combinations, built from furniture-grade materials. You’ll mostly find traditional-looking mantels with detailed woodwork. The goal is for the fireplace to look like a finished centerpiece instead of a basic wall feature.
This is why sizing is tied more closely to mantel dimensions than broad wall-width options. It’s also why pricing is so much higher for these products than so many other brands in the space.
Sound, Software, and Controls
Another defining characteristic of MagikFlame is integrated audio, including crackling fire sounds and optional nature soundscapes like rain, thunder, or ocean waves.
You can control everything with a handheld remote or a Bluetooth-enabled mobile app. You’ll get software-based updates over Wi-Fi, too, so new flame visuals and features roll in over time without having to change hardware.
Heating and Everyday Use
MagikFlame fireplaces also come with an infrared quartz heater to heat spaces up to 1,000 square feet. Flames can operate independently of heat for year-round use, too. Like other electric fireplaces, there’s no venting, no combustion, and no ash to manage.
There’s clearly a lot to love about MagikFlame. But is it worth the higher price? Or are you better off saving money and getting better flexibility through a brand like Dimplex? We’ll take a closer look at MagikFlame vs Dimplex below and let YOU decide.
MagikFlame vs Dimplex: Side-by-Side Comparison
These are two of the best brands in the electric fireplace industry - we want to make that clear. You can’t go wrong either way. There’s some overlap between the MagikFlame vs Dimplex, after all. But one of these is probably a better fit for your home, goals, and budget than the other.
Flame Technology
Nothing looks as realistic as MagikFlame’s HoloFlame®, a patented system that projects real video fire onto a physical log set. You get a wood-fire look with visible ember glow and smoke-like movement. It’s really cool.
Dimplex has a few distinct types of flame technology across its lineup, though. The original Dimplex Flame Effect is fine for some people, but you can upgrade to deeper-firebox realism in Revillusion, and true 3D Opti-Myst/Optimyst flames that use water vapor and LED lighting.
Our advice is to look at videos of both brands in action and see which aligns with your preferences for how flames look. This is somewhat subjective.
Fireplace Types and Designs
While both brands create electric fireplaces, there are nuances in the types and designs you’ll have access to between MagikFlame vs Dimplex.
MagikFlame is primarily an insert + mantel brand. So ask yourself - do you want a finished furniture surround? If not, this is probably not the right fit. If the answer is yes, you’ll then have to choose the insert system that pairs with it.
You get way more options with Dimplex: long linear fireplaces (Ignite family), built-ins, portrait formats, log sets, and modular water-vapor cassettes. You can make your fireplace part of a media wall, a tight bedroom corner, a commercial lobby build, or a retrofit of an existing opening. The possibilities are endless with Dimplex!
Sound Effects
Another important distinction between Dimplex vs MagikFlame is the noise side of things. Sound is a headline feature for MagikFlame. Units have built-in speakers with crackling fire audio, plus optional nature soundtracks like rain, thunder, and ocean waves.
Dimplex doesn’t build sound into its units. The brand just focuses on amazing visuals, lighting, and intuitive heat controls. If that’s a dealbreaker for you, then you’ll probably want to stick with MagikFlame or one of the other brands we carry that makes noise.
Available Sizes and Installation Options
Like we’ve said throughout this comparison of MagikFlame vs Dimplex, you have way fewer options to choose from with one of these brands. That’s MagikFlame. In contrast, Dimplex has something for every space. That includes:
- 20”
- 30”
- 36”
- 40”
- 42”
- 48”
- 50”
- 60”
- 66”
- 74”
- 86”
- 88”
- 100”
You’ll find the perfect fit in Dimplex if you need to match a specific wall width, framing plan, and layout. On that note, you can get in touch with our customer service team for a personalized recommendation based on your space.
Heating Performance and Everyday Use
Fireplaces from both brands can produce supplemental heat. Neither manufacturer makes units that produce whole-home heat, though. So set your expectations there. These are more about the vibe.
That being said, MagikFlame offers an infrared quartz heater for zone heating in spaces up to 1,000 square feet under ideal conditions. On the other hand, Dimplex uses multiple heating methods, including models with ComfortSaver technology to provide supplemental heat.
But you can also turn heat off with MagikFlame and Dimplex fireplaces and just enjoy the flame effects. That’s a shared feature that really stands out between the two brands.
Media, Lighting, and Controls
MagikFlame’s calling card, aside from flame realism, is customization. You gain access to 30 flame styles and many more sound themes in the media library. You can adjust your fireplace with a remote or the Bluetooth mobile app.
Dimplex gives you tons of control and customization in its fireplaces, too. The difference is that you can adjust the ember bed and lighting to get different vibes from your fireplace. As for control, you’ll have to refer to the specific model you’re considering. Some Dimplex fireplaces have remote and on-board controls, while others offer app-based features.
Cost Considerations
This is a big point of comparison between MagikFlame vs Dimplex - which makes sense for you from a financial perspective? As we mentioned a few times in this guide, MagikFlame is much more expensive - often twice as much as a comparable Dimplex unit.
We’re not saying you should shop based on price alone. Just that you should ask yourself if a little extra flame realism is worth a few thousand more dollars. OR, if you’d rather spend that extra money on other home upgrades and go with a Dimplex unit.
Reliability, Support, and Warranty
You should look beyond the purchase and think about which brand is better after the fact, too. Dimplex and MagikFlame both have strong reputations for customer service and reliability, but there are caveats to consider.
MagikFlame is a small manufacturer that sells direct to consumers, builds its fireplaces in limited volumes, and backs everything up with a 1-year warranty. You also get a 30-day in-home trial.
Dimplex takes things a little further, with warranties ranging from 1-5 years depending on the specific product in question. The company offers exceptional customer service before, during, and after the sale.
But if you’re going to buy a Dimplex unit, it should be through us here at The Great Fire Company. This way, you can get the best deal online (we have a price-matching guarantee) and even better support.
Wrapping Up Our Dimplex vs MagikFlame Comparison
We hope this MagikFlame vs Dimplex comparison has left you with clarity on where each sits in the electric fireplace market. More importantly, which brand best suits your needs and budget.
MagikFlame is built around a single, realism-first insert experience, while Dimplex offers far more flexibility across sizes, installation styles, flame technologies, and price points.
Whether you’re looking for a see-through electric fireplace or a wall-mount electric fireplace, we think Dimplex is the smarter choice in almost every scenario. Get in touch with our team at The Great Fire Company for one-on-one support and let’s find the perfect fireplace for YOUR space!